Sunday, 28 August 2011

Psychologist Paul Martin speaks now

Contributor to Speak Now, psychologist Paul Martin, reports back on his meeting with the Prime Minister in Canberra...

 In my meetings with MP’s and with the Prime Minister in Canberra, one angle that they say is new to them is of the connection between mental health and same sex marriage.  

The information I give them is based on my 25 years as a psychologist specialising in the area of same-sex attraction and the most recent research-based public statements from the American Psychological Association.

I talk to them about the fact that everyone is brought up in a homophobic world and almost everyone who is same-sex attracted will absorb these negative messages and, naturally, will have beliefs about themselves, including being 'defective' and socially excluded. 

The statistics regarding mental and physical health problems in gay and lesbian populations are extremely negative.  This includes recent Australian data which suggests that gays and lesbians are more than 4 times more likely to attempt suicide and have much higher rates of mental disorders and physical health issues.  This is a direct result of ‘internalised homophobia.’

One of the internalised homophobic beliefs is that same sex relationships are not as valid or valuable as their heterosexual peers.

According to the research, and my clinical experience, when the issue of same-sex marriage is debated, the negative rhetoric stated by community leaders leads to psychological distress for gays and lesbians and their children.  This is due to the fact that what they are hearing confirms what they already believe about themselves.   If they were brought up in a society which valued same sex relationships, the non-evidence based words spoken by these people could be easily brushed off as being somewhat silly, or a result of bias and stigma.

Research clearly demonstrates that when heterosexual people value gays and lesbians’ relationships, the psychological wellbeing of those people increases significantly.  In talking with politicians I mention anecdotes of friends of mine from Canada and Norway who say that when they are with a group of people which includes gays and lesbians, the level of worth seems palpably higher as they proudly introduce their husbands and wives and show off their wedding albums.   When they come to Australia they say how amazed they are at the general difference in the levels of wellbeing. They are saddened by the sorts of words they hear spoken by the opponents of same-sex marriage.

The best way to stop this ongoing distress for same-sex attracted people and to automatically and instantly improve their psychological wellbeing is to allow the choice to marry.  This won’t solve the psychological issues overnight, but it will be an important step towards improving the mental health of many thousands of Australians.

Three contributors to Speak Now meet with the Prime Minister




Prof. Kerryn Phelps is shown on the left, with her wife, Jackie Stricker.  Rodney Croome is next to the Prime Minister, Julia Gillard, and on the extreme right is Brisbane psychologist Paul Martin. They are joined by the tireless national spokesperson for PFlag Australia, Shelley Argent. 

Phelps, Croome and Martin have all contributed pieces to Speak Now.

The group met the P.M. and another 14 politicians in Canberra last week to raise awareness of the human story behind marriage equality.

Coverage in The Weekend Australian

Last week, some 30 Federal parliamentarians reported to the House on Greens MP Adam Bandt's earlier motion that they should consult with their constituents and report back to the House.

In The Weekend Australian Sat. Aug. 27, 'editor at large'  Paul Kelly reported this development under the headline 'MPs won't jump on same-sex bandwagon'.

Kelly's opening sentence referred to 'mounting evidence' that any move in the current parliament to allow marriage equality is 'unlikely to prevail'.  His 'evidence' is based on the fact that 20 of those MPs signalled their rejection of the possibility, with only seven indicating support.

As there are 150 MPs (and 76 Senators), only a biased commentator could read this as definitive, or as countervailing the generally favorable community opinion, as evidenced in a number of opinion polls. 

Kelly has to acknowledge that this 'cannot offer a definitive guide', so he resorts to studying 'the omens', which he declares are 'apparent'.  It's not until his eighth paragraph that he admits that 'opinion has moved and moved fast'.

Elsewhere in the same issue, conservative columnist Christopher Pearson, who says he came out of the closet in 1971, indulges in specious religious rationale to back his assertion that 'formal recognition of same-sex cuples is tantamount to the dictatorship of relativism'.  The headline recommends that 'Parliament should vote against gay marriage'.

Pearson links the issue to an argument about female priests, and says respect ought to be paid to the '2000-year-old tradition, following Christ's example at the Last Supper, that the priesthood be exclusively male', tagging his opinion with this bizarre statement: 'Men are categorically unfit to be nuns, as are women to be priests and blokes to be brides.'

No-one is expecting that conservative churches should be forced to conduct wedding rituals for same-sex couples.  It is the State that recognises marriage unions and it is high time that the secular status of marriage be clearly demarcated.  Churches will continue to do whatever it is they do.

These pieces are further examples of mere opinion posing as journalism.  Marginalising marriage equality by representing it solely as a 'Greens campaign' ignores the human story unfolding here.

Tuesday, 23 August 2011

Carl Katter distances himself from his politician brother

Carl Katter, half-brother to independent Senator Bob Katter, expressed his concern that his brother has spoken out scornfully on the issue of marriage equality.

"I don't know how he can target a minority and persecute them, in the way he has," Carl Katter said on Network Ten's 6.30 program.  "It's hurtful, it's dangerous, it's damaging... His gross generalisations are inappropriate in today's society, " he told host George Negus. "I don't understand his motives."

Conservative Christians fight back...

Responding to surveys suggesting that suggest that 53% of people identifying as Christian support same-sex marriage, a large group of church leaders are lobbying Federal politicians not to change the Marriage Act.

These leaders include the Anglican Archbishop of Sydney Peter Jensen, the Catholic Archbishop of Sydney George Pell, Lutheran Church president Mike Semmler, Orthodox Archbishop of Australia Paul Sliba, Salvation Army commissioner Raymond Finger and Presbyterian moderator-general David Jones.

MPs were due to report report to parliament today on their consultations with constituents to gauge support for same-sex marriage.  Support -- and opposition -- was noted from all sides.

Catholic Labor MP Graham Perrett said he supported a change to recognise gay marriage because it would protect young gay people from abuse.  Mr Perrett has two gay brothers.  He said his Catholic faith was a “private matter” and he had no qualms about speaking out in support of gay marriage.

Thursday, 18 August 2011

Just whom does the Australian Christian Lobby represent?

If a recent opinion poll is anything to go by, a majority of Australian Christians believe same-sex couples should be allowed to marry.


A Galaxy Research poll, released 16 August, found that 53% of Australians who identify as Christians support same-sex marriage, while 41% oppose.  67% of non-Christians support it.

A spokesperson for Australian Marriage Equality, Malcolm McPherson, himself a Christian, says the poll shows church leaders and Christian lobbyists who oppose same-sex marriage are not representative. 

The website Same Same reports on number of mainstream Christian ministers who have spoken out in favour of the reform.  See their full report at  http://www.samesame.com.au/

“Christian groups that oppose marriage equality like the Australian Christian Lobby are entitled to their view, but they do not represent the majority of Australian Christians”, McPherson said.  “Clearly, most Australian Christians believe same-sex marriage is consistent with Christian values like justice, love, compassion and fidelity, not opposed to these values.”

SameSame reports that Christian leaders who have given their support to the campaign come from Uniting, Anglican and Baptist churches across Australia, and include Sydney minister and 2GB radio host Rev Bill Crews, who emphasised the distinction between religious and civil marriages in their report:

“In a secular and non discriminatory society gay couples should be as free to marry as any other human couple. If people wish to be married within a religious or spiritual institution’s framework then they should accept the rites and rules of that institution. However it is the state that legitimises all marriages.”

SameSame also quotes Melbourne Baptist Pastor Matt Glover, who says allowing same-sex marriages will benefit marriage as an institution:


“As a Christian minister, I believe that marriage is under threat from many angles, but also believe that recognizing same-sex unions will help return marriage to its rightful place in society.”

Another Baptist Minister, Rev. Nathan Nettleton of South Yarra, has contributed a substantial chapter to Speak Now titled: "Supporting Same-Sex Marriage as a heterosexual, Bible-believing Baptist Pastor." 

After his recent appearance on ABC TV's program Compass, Rev. Nettleton was asked to state that although he is an ordained Baptist pastor, the opinions expressed were his personal views and were not seeking to represent the official position of any union of Baptist churches, or the majority opinion of Baptist people.

The group of Christian clergy known as Christians 4 Equality have now joine the Unitarians, Quakers, and the Metroplitan Community Church in publicly supporting same-sex marriage in Australia.

The Rabbinic Council of Progressive Rabbis of Australasia put their support for same-sex marriage on the record back in June.

However, the Australian Christian Lobby, which organised the rally in Canberra,  has dismissed the poll results as absurd.

"Certainly my work with Evangelical, Catholic and Orthodox churches leaves me in no doubt that the great majority of their adherents don't support same-sex marriage," said Mr Wallace, the Lobby's Managing Director.

"I think a simple additional question on the poll that determined if the person actually attended a church might have made the result more informative," he said.

The Australian Greens responded to the poll results saying it gives a real reflection of the views of the Christian community.

"This poll confirms what we have known for some time - most Christians, like other everyday Australians, have no objection to marriage equality and believe that same-sex couples should have the same rights as heterosexual couples," the Greens' spokesperson for sexual orientation and gender identity, Senator Sarah Hanson-Young, said.

"All too often, we hear from a narrow section of the community, who beat the drum loudly against equality for same-sex couples and in doing so claim to represent the views of all Australian Christians.

"Over several years, I have been contacted by many Christians in strong support of marriage equality - mothers, fathers, sisters and brothers who believe in treating all people with dignity and respect. Indeed many Christian leaders have been pushing this reform for some time." 

Listen to Parliamentary debate

You can listen to the audio file of parliamentary debate on a motion by the Greens Member of the House, Adam Bandt (from November 15, 2010) after Bandt had called on parliamentarians so seek out the views of their constituents on marriage equality for same-sex partners, here:

http://australianpolitics.com/2010/11/15/house-of-representatives-debates-gay-marriage-resolution.html


Bandt's motion read, "That this House:

          (1) notes there is:
                   (a) a growing list of countries that allow same-sex couples to marry including the Netherlands, Belgium, Norway, SPain, Canada and South Africa; and
         (b) widespread support for equal marriage in the Australian community; and
(2) calls on all parliamentarians to gauge their constituents’ views on the issue of marriage equality.